The
following was written as a response to an excerpt from Alexander Pope’s “Essay
on Criticism.”
Eric Hansen
AP English
Mrs. Funkhouser
Alexander Pope Quote Essay Response
What We Think
We Know
Consider the following words: knowledge, light, and truth. All exist as intangible elements in our universe, yet many act as if they can handle such ideas with unrepressed ease. Pride, arrogance, and a will or drive to always profess more intelligence than another appears to compose the main body of society in today’s world when in reality a vast amount of knowledge remains untouched. As a result, people maintain the assumption that they themselves are great thinkers, just like Raskolnikov in Crime & Punishment, who considers himself a “superman” until he discovers his fallibility. I submit the truly great thinkers never considered themselves marvelous.
Alexander Pope, in his work “An Essay on Criticism,” describes a “little learning [as] a dangerous thing,” and too often do people assume they have learned enough. I find situational irony in the essay’s title as it pertains to criticism, yet the body of the work expands on learning and the amount of knowledge one attains. The irony derives from classes all over the world engaged in discussion about topics in which little is known, yet these classes take pride in their assumptions to the point of haughtiness. I cannot number the instances when people project their own inferences as a credible source when they cannot claim any experience to the topic or idea. Given: Learning ensues from ignorance, but I declare people ought not to arrogantly state their opinions as fact. Rather they should remain humble and teachable in order to gain experience and grow. If people do not have the will to “drink deep” as Pope states, then they should “taste not the Pierian spring.” In other words, if someone does not have the presence of mind to study out a topic in its totality, then he or she does not have the right to produce reliable remarks on the subject.
Sensations fill the universe and stimulate the human mind, and many times people become addicted to the sensation and the bliss they experience as a result. Whether the stimulus excogitates from nicotine in a cigarette, endorphins triggered by muscle stress, or intoxication from alcohol, some people begin to crave only the sensation and will work only to find more exciting processes. Likewise, knowledge can impose similar effects, resulting in people’s enjoyment solely in the momentary stirring after a partial enlightenment instead of eternal satisfaction in pure light and truth. Unlike alcohol or other harmful substances, “drinking largely” from the spring of knowledge produces long-lasting growth and happiness. The difference lies in what each is composed of, where the alcohol only mimics the appearance of something that brings pleasure. “By their fruits ye shall know them,” and society should not judge only by first impression or outer appearance.